Heckle and Chide: Results of a Randomized Road Safety Intervention in Kenya - Working Paper 169

Publication Info

Publication Type

• Working Papers

Download

• Download (PDF, 1.43 MB)

Research Topics

• Fragile States

CGD Expert

• James Habyarimana

Article

• Bus-Riders of the World Unite! (New York Times Freakanomics Blog)

Events

• Heckle and Chide: Results of a Randomized Road Safety Intervention in Kenya
• Time to Build a Trans-Africa Road Network: New
  Analysis of the Costs and Benefits, and Preliminary
  Suggestions on How the Donors Could Make it Happen

Rights and Permissions

We welcome the use of CGD work-just let us know in advance! For contact information see our Rights & Permissions page. CGD rights and permissions are managed under the terms of the Creative Commons license below.

James Habyarimana and William Jack

04/15/2009

In countries with poor enforcement of road-safety standards, risky drivers endanger their passengers and those in other vehicles. In such an environment, reducing the costs that dangerous drivers impose on other road users is difficult. This paper evaluates an intervention that aims instead to reduce the costs a bad drivers impose on their own passengers, who face a collective-action problem when choosing whether to speak up when a driver compromises their safety. In the experiment, messages designed to lower the costs of speaking up were placed in a random sample of over 1,000 minibuses in Kenya. Analysis of comprehensive insurance data covering a two year period that spanned the intervention shows that insurance claims for treated vehicles decreased by one-half to two-thirds, compared with the control group. In addition, claims involving an injury or death decreased by at least 50 percent. Passenger and driver surveys indicate that passenger heckling contributed to this reduction in accidents

This paper was made possible in part by support from the Australian Agency for International Development.